The Complete Guide to Halal ETF Investing for Muslim Investors – IslamicFinanceGuru
Exchange traded funds (ETFs) are one of the most popular ways to invest in the stock market. Moreover they have long been hailed as one of the best options for the average investor.
Warren Buffet famously outperformed a hedge fund over 10 years by simply buying an ETF and holding it. In contrast the hedge fund would regularly buy and sell investments. Tales like these illustrate why ETFs are all the rage.
In this article we will cover ETFs blow-by-blow, including a list of all the Halal ETFs in one place.
What are ETFs?
Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are funds traded on a stock exchange (such as the Nasdaq or the London Stock Exchange). A fund consists of a pool of money from various investors allocated for a specific investing purpose. This purpose can range from:
- tracking an index (group of stocks such as the FTSE 100 or the S&P 500). These are the most popular types of ETFs.
- investing in specific commodities (e.g. gold or oil).
- following certain themes (e.g. clean energy or technology firms).
- getting exposure to foreign markets (e.g. East Asian markets or European markets).
- Investing in fixed-income products that pay a yield (e.g. Sukuks or real estate).
As ETFs are traded openly on exchanges they are more accessible to investors than regular funds. Combined with the fact that you get exposure to many different companies, it is easy to see why they are recommended as an easy convenient choice for most investors. More on this later.
Are ETFs halal?
This depends on what the fund consists of. The easiest way to find this out is to look for ETFs that have been certified as sharia-complaint by scholars. Otherwise you’d have to do a manual check.
When doing a manual check, you firstly make sure that the ETF actually holds the underlying assets. ETFs that synthetically create the same effect using derivative instruments are not permissible to invest in.
You then need to determine whether all the companies or assets in a fund are halal. If so, then yes the entire ETF is halal.
For more detail on the screening criteria for companies, we have a stock screening article and halal stock screener course that goes into more detail and breaks down each step of the process. We also offer Cur8, a platform offering pre-vetted investment options.
If the fund contains a small number of non-compliant companies or assets (less than 5%), then the ETF is still halal to invest in but you should purify your profits by giving that % away in charity.
In practice, it is quite difficult for the average investor to manually screen a stocks and shares ETF. This is because ETFs generally tend to have anywhere from 30 to hundreds of different active holdings. For this reason, it might be best to stick to the certified halal ETFs. At least until some automated solution can be developed that can speed up the screening process.
What are the pros and cons of ETFs?
Let’s take a look at some of the pros and cons of investing in ETFs.
The case for ETFs
- They save you time. Finding and tracking investments is a time-consuming process. Investing in ETFs allow you to focus on the things that really matter to you.
- Easily accessible and liquid (can be converted to cash with relative ease) as they are traded on exchanges.
- Less risky than individual stock picking. This is because generally there are many different assets in an ETF. This offers you protection from bad performance from any single aspect of the fund, as it won’t have much impact on the overall value of the fund.
- Give you diversification at a low cost. Investing in many companies yourself will cost you loads with brokers fees (unless of course you use zero cost brokers).
- Provide broad exposure to wider investment themes. Let’s say you want to invest in clean energy companies as you believe there is a lucrative opportunity there. Instead of trying to pick individual companies in an area that may not be your area of expertise, you could simply buy a clean energy focused ETF.
- Gain access to otherwise inaccessible investments. ETFs have a sizeable pot of money. This allows them to access investments that may not otherwise be open to you as a small everyday investor. For example, investing in unlisted companies.
- Leverage the expertise of the fund manager. For ETFs that don’t track an index, a fund manager will select companies to invest in using their expertise.
The case against ETFs
- DIY stock picking can be more lucrative. You will rarely make astronomical returns through ETF investing. They tend to offer steady returns over the long run. Talented individual investors can outperform by picking stocks themselves.
- Not as fun as finding companies yourself. This is for those who are really passionate about investing and finding exciting companies.
- You may be over-diversifying. The strong performing assets/companies in an ETF could be held back by the weaker investments. If you are focussed on pure growth of your portfolio, it may be a smarter strategy to focus on a smaller number of holdings. However with this comes more risk.
- Follow the market in down times. ETFs provide you with broad exposure to an index, sector, or market. If any of those experience a downturn, the ETF will likely follow it.
- Additional management fees compared to individual stocks. You don’t pay management or admin fees for holding stocks. However in return you do get the ease and simplicity of investing in an ETF.
So in short, investing in ETFs is a great low-cost, low-effort way to gain exposure into specific themes. However there is the potential to make more through picking stocks yourselves. With all this in mind, let’s look at who ETFs are good for.
Who are ETFs good for?
DIY stock picking is difficult and can be time-consuming to learn the ropes. ETFs can be a great way to get started investing. You can then take your time to learn about DIY stock investing if you so desire.
However don’t expect guaranteed returns. Whilst it is true that in general, many ETFs have performed well in the long term it doesn’t mean this will continue. So doing your due diligence and understanding the risks is still important!
A crucial mistake beginners make is getting spooked by market crashes and selling everything. This usually means they lock in their losses and tend to miss the recovery. Having an investment strategy is crucial for success. We will cover some strategies later.
ETFs have historically performed better over the long-term, similar to most investments. ETFs generally track a group of companies. This means for short-term large spikes in the price, you would need the price to spike for a significant proportion of those companies. This rarely happens. What tends to happen is for companies’ share prices to increase steadily over time.
Whilst it is rare for the price of an ETF to spike suddenly, they can crash heavily in a day. This can happen when there is a market wide crash that affects a large proportion of the ETF’s holdings. This means that for most people, ETFs are best suited for long-term investing.
How to value ETFs
Similarly to funds, ETFs have a net asset value (NAV), which gives you the value of the fund when you take all its assets and subtract its liabilities. This can be found on the issuer’s website.
You want to compare the net asset value per share with the share price. If there’s a mismatch then this could be quite informative. If the share price is larger than the NAV then this is a good indicator that the ETF may be overvalued.
Conversely if the share price is less than the NAV, this could be an indicator of it being undervalued. You should also look deeper to understand why there is such a deviation in the first place.
For ETFs that track an index, a tracking error between the two prices is common. You just need to make sure it’s not excessive.
When comparing ETFs, do take into account the fees they charge. Ideally you would look at both the current share price and the fees.
ETF fees and charges
As ETFs tend to be more passively managed than normal funds, they usually charge less fees. There are two main fee types you want to look out for.
- Total Expense Ratio (TER) – this covers all annual management, trading, and admin costs. These tend to vary between 0.3% and 0.7%.
- Foreign exchange fees – levied if you buy an ETF that is in a different currency.
How are ETFs taxed?
The tax treatment of ETFs will be the same as it is for stocks and shares.
For UK investors, this means you could potentially be subject to capital gains tax or dividend tax. You’d incur a capital gains tax if you sell your ETF for a profit larger than your capital gains tax allowance for the year. The dividend tax is levied on any dividends received over your annual dividend allowance.
However, if you buy an ETF in an ISA (individual savings account) or SIPP (self-invested personal pension) then neither tax will apply no matter the amount of profit or dividends you make. So always try to make use of an ISA or SIPP where possible!
How to pick an ETF
There are a number of things to consider when searching for ETFs to invest in.
Firstly, you need to understand your own investing goals. Have a plan for what you want to achieve and only invest what you can afford to.
Understanding your own risk profile is also key. Ask yourself whether you would be comfortable investing in high-risk high-reward investments, where drawdowns of over 30% are quite common. You may be better suited to more stable investments that aim for around 8-10% a year. In general, not investing in line with your risk tolerance can lead to poor investment decisions.
For example, in the case where you don’t have a high risk tolerance. If you invest in a high risk asset which suddenly drops 30%. You may panic and sell and then miss the 70% gain it might make over the next year.
Then, it is just a matter of using this information to decide what types of investments you want to make. You may want to focus on certain high growth areas, such as clean energy or emerging markets. Or you might just want to keep things simple and invest in funds that track an index.
ETFs and dividends
Dividends are an important feature for many investors. These are cash payments companies pay out to their investors from their profits. Some ETFs will definitely have dividend-generating assets.
ETFs have two options for dealing with dividends:
- Reinvest the dividends on behalf of each investor. Reinvesting dividends has historically led to better returns. Take a study looking at the performance of the S&P 500 between 1980 and 2019. It found that 75% of the returns came from reinvested dividends.
- Distribute the dividends to each investor. This will diminish your long term returns. However your investing strategy may be to invest in dividends paying investments to receive a regular income stream. In this case, opting for ETFs that pay out dividends will be the right option.
To find out how an ETF deals with dividends, either check its full title or the issuer’s website. ETFs that reinvest dividends tend to have ‘Acc.’ in the name. ETFs that pays out dividends have either ‘Inc’ or ‘Dist.’ in their name.
ETFs are generally known for being passively managed. However recently actively managed ETFs have become more popular. The most famous example are the ARK ETFs managed by Cathie Wood. She actively picks stocks to invest in that tie in with her investing theme of disruptive innovation.
However with this comes higher fees as the fund manager has a greater involvement. Another thing to keep in mind is that many active ETFs are US-listed and are inaccessible to UK investors for the most part.
Sukuks are a sharia-compliant alternative to conventional bond products. In a nutshell, Sukuk represent an ownership interest in a pool of assets. These assets generate revenue which are distributed to the Sukuk holders. For more information on Sukuk, check out our deep dive here and our fixed income investing guide here.
2020 saw the release of the first ever Sukuk ETF, a huge development in this space. To date, this looks to be the only Sukuk ETF available. One to keep an eye on for the future.
Real Estate Investment Trusts ETFs
Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) are trusts that hold real estate from which they earn rental returns. A REIT ETF is just a REIT that is also listed on a stock exchange, which makes it easier to trade. Otherwise you would have to access a REIT from a regular fund which isn’t as accessible to the ordinary investor.
Similarly to Sukuk, there are not a great deal of options available in this space. Another one to watch for the future!
ETF investing strategies
Whilst investing in ETFs is a lot simpler than investing in stocks yourself, there are still a few different ways to invest in them.
Buy and hold
This is the simplest strategy. Simply invest and hold for the long-term.
A great way to supplement this strategy is to continue to invest. Many investors adopt the dollar cost averaging approach. In this approach, you invest a certain amount every period regardless of the most recent price.
For example you might invest an additional £100 every month out of your pay-check. This allows you to not worry about trying to time the market. Buying regularly will naturally capture any spikes or dips in price, resulting in a smoothed out average purchase price.
This is a great way to take emotion and the latest market hype out of the decision process.
In this approach, investors invest mainly in ETFs and then supplement with other assets, such as stocks.
For example, let’s take a look at Musa. He has 75% of his portfolio in sharia-compliant ETFs. He allocates the remaining 25% to investing in individual stocks. This approach allows him to manage his risk and also be able to invest in individual stocks targeting higher returns.
If he doesn’t want to go down the individual stock route then he could instead invest in actively managed funds that target a higher return than ETFs.
Do your due diligence when searching for actively managed funds. Many claim to be able to offer better returns than ETFs but you want to see proof of this via their historic return.
Whilst past performance doesn’t necessarily promise future reward, it could be a good sign that the fund manager knows what they are doing.
For ideas of other areas of investing to supplement your ETFs, check out our halal investment comparison engine.
When to sell an ETF
One of the most difficult parts of investing is knowing when to sell. The answer for this will depend on each individual investor. Only you are aware of what your investing goals are.
Generally speaking, you should only invest money that you don’t need right now. If however you come into a situation where you require money then yes this would be an appropriate time to sell.
Otherwise the best way to know when to sell is to have a good understanding of why you bought an ETF in the first place. If the reason you bought is no longer valid, then this is a good sign that perhaps it is time to sell.
However if your thesis remains intact and you don’t need the money then why sell? If the urge to sell is unbearable, then a suitable compromise perhaps would be to trim a small amount of your holding, so you can lock in some profits but crucially still remain invested for the long run.
How to buy ETFs
This guide wouldn’t be complete without a word on how exactly to buy ETFs. You buy ETFs the same way you would buy stocks and shares.
- First find the ETF(s) that you are interested in.
- Don’t forget to screen them for sharia compliance!
- Then look for a broker that offers them.
- If you want to learn more about the different broker options there are, do check out this article we wrote.
- Open an account with the broker.
- Deposit the money you want to invest and use this to buy the ETF(s).
List of sharia-certified ETFs
Here is a list of sharia-certified ETFs to get you started. Please note, that not all of these may be available in your region. Also make sure to do your own due diligence! We have not reviewed all of these from an investing perspective. This list has just been collated to hopefully make your lives easier.
- iShares MSCI World Islamic UCITS ETF
- iShares MSCI EM Islamic UCITS ETF
- iShares MSCI USA Islamic UCITS ETF
- Wahed FTSE USA Shariah ETF
- SP Funds Dow Jones Global Sukuk ETF
- SP Funds S&P 500 Sharia Industry Exclusions ETF
- Wealthsimple Shariah World Equity Index ETF
- SP Funds S&P Global REIT Sharia ETF
- Almalia Sanlam Active Shariah Global Equity UCITS ETF
Alternatives to ETFs
So what are the alternatives to ETF investing and how do they differ?
DIY Stock Picking
This is where you go it alone and find stocks yourself. The potential for reward is greater here but so is the risk. It will also take a lot of time to learn the ropes and to actively manage your investments.
A good halfway option is to use halal stock screeners, such as Zoya and others. This allows you to gain access to pre-vetted, sharia-compliant stocks in a relatively risk-controlled way that you couldn’t otherwise access.
An alternative is to sit our halal stock screening course where we teach you how to sharia screen individual stocks. The advantage of this is that you won’t need to be dependent on anyone else’s assessments and can a judgement call yourself.
You could skip index ETFs and just go straight to index funds. They also track the performance of certain indexes. The main difference is that these are not listed on exchanges. Therefore you can’t buy and sell at any point during market opening hours. You would have to wait for a set point in the day where you could cash out.
These are the actively managed, non-exchange listed options. So similarly to index funds you can’t buy and sell as easily as you could for ETFs. With this option you are essentially paying for the fund manager’s expertise and banking on them to outperform the ETFs.
An investment trust is very similar to a fund. It also pools money from many investors to invest in a basket of various assets. They are also actively managed similarly to mutual funds. The difference is they are structured as companies which then list on stock exchanges. As they are exchange listed, you can buy and sell them the same way you would with ETFs.
So there we have it. Sharia-compliant ETFs are a great option for investors who either don’t have the desire or the time to individually analyse stocks.
If you’re a hands-on investor who wants to go it alone, ETFs can still be a useful way to gain exposure into different sectors. Particularly if you are interested in areas of the stock market that may be inaccessible to an individual investor, such as foreign markets.
If you want to learn more about other areas of investing, check our Halal Investing 101 Guides and halal stock screener course. If you’d prefer to move straight into investing, be sure to check out Cur8’s selection of pre-vetted options.