Islamic FinancePersonal Finance

Is a Mortgage Haram? A Fatwa Analysis – Sh. Atabek/Sh. Haitham

Many Muslims have started using Islamic mortgages in the UK (you can compare between them really easily here). But as we all know, many Muslims continue to use conventional mortgages despite the prohibition on interest in Islam. Some of these Muslims argue that in fact conventional mortgages are halal.

They use two arguments.

Camp A argues that, while a conventional mortgage is usually haram, taking out a conventional mortgage is a necessity today (and that halal mortgages are not really halal). So, by default, a conventional mortgage is allowed.

Camp B argues that, actually, conventional mortgages are halal because they’re not truly “riba” or a “debt” in Islamic law.

We disagree with both Camp A and Camp B. Here’s our reasons why.

Camp A: taking out a mortgage is a necessity

Camp A includes several very respectable scholars. At IFG we respectfully disagree with these scholars and our detailed views are set out in an earlier article.

In summary, one of the key reasons why Camp A thinks taking a conventional mortgage is permissible is because they think that halal mortgages are not really Islamic. So the only basis to buy a mortgage is if there’s a need, and finding whichever one is cheapest.

We of course think Islamic mortgages are Islamic and share our reasons here. If you agree with us then obviously going for a halal mortgage over a conventional mortgage makes complete sense.

The second key reason used by Camp A, is that there is a necessity to own a home. We disagree as the threshold for “necessity” in Islam is really high (think – destitute and homeless kind-of-necessity) and given that most people can quite effectively rent, this is not an argument that works.

We are not alone in our view that using the argument of “necessity” only works for the direst of cases – not for everyone.

Shaykh Haitham Al-Haddad has a great summary on this.

IslamQA also unsurprisingly considers conventional mortgage as haram.

Mufti Muhammad ibn Adam also takes the same stance here.

Camp B: Those who say conventional mortgages are halal

There are considerably fewer scholars in this camp. The most prominent among them in recent years from the UK is Shaykh Atabek Shukurov. He argues here and here that conventional mortgages should not be understood as the classic riba-based debt in Islamic law.

We respectfully disagree.

Sh. Atabek’s argument in a nutshell is:

  1. Forget the terminology being used (e.g. “interest” and “bank”) and focus just on the actual steps that take place.
  2. The bank isn’t just giving you money for you to spend as you wish. It is paying you money for you to only buy a particular property.
  3. What is actually taking place is that the bank is appointing you as its agent to buy the property on its behalf, which it is then selling to you at a marked-up price over the course of the next 2 decades.
  4. This is permissible as its just a murabaha (a murabaha contract is explained in detail here).

But this argument doesn’t work for the following reasons:

  1. The conventional Bank isn’t ever looking to buy the property: Even if we focus on the actual steps being taken, the bank isn’t appointing the debtor to buy a house for it. The bank doesn’t particularly care about the house itself. It only cares that the house has enough value to act as good security for the loan it is about to give out.To put it another way: there’s a big difference between ordering a valuation report and undertaking a full survey and in-person visit with a view to buying it to actually use.
  2. Misunderstanding the banking world: The analysis also completely mischaracterises the banking world – which is really big on securing a debt with an asset and/or guarantee. You see, a secured loan is pretty appealing and can easily be repackaged up and sold to other banks. But no one in this transaction really cares about the asset securing the loan – other than that it exists. (And it is precisely because of this lack of care into the asset that we had the credit crunch).So the banking world is not in the business of buying assets. It is in the business of financing projects and assets and making sure the loan is backed up by some form of safety for itself in case of default. That usually means either foreclosing on the valuable security that it has been granted or going after the debtor for the money (or both).
  3. The implications are untenable: Taken to the extreme, this argument becomes completely untenable, as it would entail that only unsecured borrowing would really be impermissible. So all a bank has to do to make its finance sharia-compliant is to specify what the debt can be used for and get security. But here’s the thing – many bank loans already do this! Banks don’t like to give someone a large amount of money without having at least some control or visibility over what its money is being spent on.Under this line of analysis then, any leveraged buyout or purchase would suddenly become halal. So car finance is fine on a specific car. A leveraged private equity buyout of a company is fine too. Credit card debt isn’t though.
  4. There is no agency agreement. While Sh. Atabek argues that we should look at the substance of the transaction, it must be noted that there is no agency agreement in place between the bank and the debtor at any point. That is because the relationship is one of creditor-debtor.
  5. Whose name is actually on the property? In the Al Rayan Islamic mortgage for example, the freehold of the property is in the name of Al Rayan. In the conventional mortgage the freehold is in the name of the debtor from start to finish. At no point does the conventional bank take ownership over the asset and sell onwards.
  6. How does the accountant treat the mortgage? Well, the accountant treats the mortgage as a debt. At no point does the property itself come onto the balance sheet of the bank.
  7. Common sense analysis: The biggest reason for us is that simply on a common-sense analysis basis, everyone would conclude that a conventional mortgage is an interest-bearing loan. The banks think it is interest, the consumers think it is interest, and it is treated as interest by the accountants, HMRC and regulators. Sometimes its best to take things at face value.

Conclusions: conventional mortgages are haram

So there you have it folks. Conventional mortgages are haram.

You can’t justify getting a conventional mortgage by saying “it is a necessity for me to buy a house and the only way I can do that cheaply is a conventional mortgage”. You can’ do that for two reasons: (1) because its not really a necessity; and (2) you can always go for an Islamic mortgage instead.

Secondly, you can’t justify getting a conventional mortgage by arguing that it is essentially just like a murabaha transaction. This mischaracterises conventional finance and would open the floodgates to basically rendering large swathes of conventional finance as halal.

So Islamic mortgages are the way to go in our view – and we’ve created a really helpful comparison tool – the first of its kind in the UK – to help you compare between Islamic mortgages available today. Let us know how you get on in the comment below!

20 Comments
, ,

Keep Reading

20 Comments. Leave new

  • Salam alaykoum brother
    You talk about islamic mortgage?
    Al rayan is the ex islamic bank of Britain which is a subsidiary of Lloyd’s bank is it not?

    Reply
  • Asslam o Alaikum, Nice article Mashallah. Many muslims in UK don’t understand the word necessity.

    Sh. Haitham also thinks that HPP model (Al Ryan & GateHouse) in UK is not halal either.

    Allah knows best.

    Jazak Allah

    Reply
  • Thank you for this, it’s so clearly articulated and makes the arguement conclusive. However our issue has been trying to get UK mortgages as expats. We haven’t found any Islamic options willing to lend to those not within the country even though the mortgaged premises is our primary UK address?

    Reply
  • The risk with Islamic banks is that it can close down, hence people go for conventional mortgages. What do you say?

    Reply
    • I don’t think that’s fair – Islamic banks have shown they last for a while. Conventional banks also are allowed to engage in the (haram) risky behaviour which leads banks to collapse, so there’s a degree of protection Islamic banks get simply because of the restrictions on them.

      Reply
  • Much respect to you for writing this article. I was stuck in the islamic mortgage mess via, ironically, a bank name LaRiba (run by Bank of Whittier in California). It is nothing but a heaping pile of lies and hypocrisy. I paid, to the last penny, the same exact amount interest compared to if I would have financed through a non-Islamic bank. Please keep at it Brother Ibrahim, this problem is rampant throughout the entire world because it is a money maker for banks. Allah SWT will reward you iA for your work.

    Reply
  • First of all Jazakumullahu Khair for all of your efforts in this field. Perhaps it has been mentioned in previous articles but I think Islamic finance goes well beyond simply halal vs haraam.

    I used to be a firm believer in renting only and avoiding any type of mortgage. However since I am now married, and the rental market becoming more difficult I have had to force myself to look again into buying a house in order to provide some stability in the home, instead of continuously looking to move every time the rent goes up.

    For me there is no need to go into details, a conventional mortgage is haraam. Anybody who argues otherwise needs to have a deep look inside their heart and realise that there arguments are satanic in nature.

    With Islamic mortgages things are slightly different. I used to believe that they were the same. In the end you are paying more for the house than it is worth, just like a conventional mortgage. However having dug a little deeper and read some of your articles, the conclusion for me is clear, if you want to buy your own home then the Islamic mortgage is really the only option.

    There are aspects to the system I don’t like, but ultimately it provides a decent halal alternative to a clearly haraam option.

    The biggest issue however for me is the lack of adoption by Muslims. If we are not going to support the Islamic Banking system then who will? Which non-muslim is going to pay more for a system that doesn’t conflict with their beliefs? It’s up to us as Muslims to make sure that we support it now, even if that means we pay more and have to deal with a little bit more pain now, so that our future generations will in sha Allah have a better system to rely on than we do at this time.

    If you are reading this, please consider the Islamic Banking system and look to replace all other conventional banking products with Islamic ones. Even if it means moving your current account and keeping your savings in an Islamic system. At the very least the Islamic system will begin to prosper. Know that for every penny we keep in high street banks, it is being used to continuously spread the cancer that is Riba as well as supporting industries that go against our beliefs.

    Rant over 😀

    Reply
  • In Ireland, there is still no islamic banks. So either keep paying high rent (exact same as the mortgage instalment) or get mortgage. Would this be taken as necessity to bring 1 of the essential needs of the family and avoid losing money to the landlord

    Reply
  • Assalam Alaykum Bothers & Sisters,
    How can I explain to a member of my family that conventional banks are investing in HARAM activities by using evidences, rather than only explaining to him what the concepts of haram vs.halal mortgages are. Indeed, he argues that Nationwide is a ethical bank and this is fine to get a mortgage from them.
    Jazakallah. Mickael

    Reply
    • salaam Mickael – point him to this website 🙂

      But really simply – Nationwide engages in lending out money to people and makes a profit from interest. That is haram.

      Reply
  • Assalamu-Alaikum,

    I must say that after 3 years of looking and reading I’ve found this website to be the most resourceful and informative.

    I am all for promoting Islamic Banks. I have an current account and savings account with them. However my predicament is this.

    My wife has Right to Buy on the council flat that we live in. I have approached all the islamic banks for a Halal Mortgage but they have all refused.

    I don’t even mind paying more in the long run as long as the mortgage is Halal.

    Al Rayan, GateHouse, UBLUK and Ahli…. None of them provide halal home finance for right to buy properties.

    So in this situation what are my choices ? If HALAL mortgages is not available for me.

    Is a conventional mortgage permissible for me ?

    I hope you can help me find a halal solution as we’ve been struggling for the last 3 years to raise a deposit amount and further funds for the shortfall and now discover that none of the HALAL BANK can provide a mortgage for us.

    Hope to hear from you soon.

    Jazakallah Khair

    Reply
    • You have looked at other halal alternatives regarding the purchase of this council property. But have you considered buying another property whether it is inside or outside of London using a halal mortgage?

      Taking a haram mortgage just because the council property will be cheaper is not a valid excuse. A simple analogy would be food. Usually haram meat is cheaper than Halal one. It does not mean it is permissible to buy the haram one. And if someone could not afford to buy halal meat, it still does not mean he is automatically allowed to buy the haram one, as he has other halal alternatives available such as buying vegetables and grains etc.

      All halal options must be closed before we can assess whether it is permissible to take out a conventional mortgage.

      (excerpt from recent Mufti exchange on this point).

      Reply
  • Mohammed Islam
    December 9, 2019 6:14 pm

    Assalamu-Alaikum brother Ibrahim Khan,

    Jazakallah khair for your reply.

    I have to clarify that I do not intend to participate in any HARAM transactions and do whole heartedly want to take out a HALAL mortgage. Even if it costs me more.

    I have never taken out any interest based loans and do not intend to start now.

    In that respect I am vigorously searching for and looking at ALL OPTIONS that are HALAL and available to me.

    I’ve read most of the articles on your website and have even looked at the opinions of Shaikh Haitham and Shaikh Atabek.

    I have also briefly read through the articles of the “Fiqh Council of North America” and the “European Fatwa Council”

    I have also considered buying other properties outside london with the HALAL mortgages available but none of these properties fall within my affordability criteria.

    It isn’t simply a matter of the council property being cheaper,(although it is a major criteria), other important aspects also include location, amenities, mosques and community, schools, work and family etc….

    In the case of my wifes council flat, it is only the fact that the Right to Buy discount has been made available (100k) that gives us the opportunity to even think about buying it. We intend to LIVE in this flat for now as it is our home, convenient for us and is local to our family and work, but intend to sell it or use it to move to a better accommodation in the future.

    Of course i can move to Glasgow and buy a house for £15,000 without interest but I’m sure you’re not suggesting that I uproot my wife away from our jobs and family and move to a location that is potentially unsafe, jobless and without future prospects and where we are no longer close enough to be able to take care of the affairs of our elderly parents. (I manage all my fathers affairs)

    I have exhausted all HALAL MORTGAGE options and can’t see any other HALAL alternatives available for me.

    I have tried Al Rayan Bank again but have been refused a HALAL mortgage as they wont finance a council property on Right to Buy. I’ve had the same response from Ahli, UBLUK and GateHouse.

    Are you able to suggest an islamic financial advisor or a Mufti that i can contact or present my case and circumstances to and get an appropriate way forward or a solution.

    Better still can you advise me on a HALAL lender that accepts Right to Buy or perhaps discuss my options with your contacts at Al Rayan and see if there is a way forward for me.

    I’m glad that there are HALAL mortgages (or close to HALAL) options available for most but like me there are still a lot of people out there with Right to Buy properties but no HALAL Mortgages options.

    It seems for now at least that a conventional mortgage route makes my life a lot more easier and affordable and removes me from a lot of hardship whereas the HALAL options are non-existent for me.

    I’m really glad to have discovered this site as i have learnt a lot. I pray that this site continues to remain an excellent source of information for all those looking to deal in HALAL finance.

    I look forward to hearing from you soon brother Ibrahim Khan.

    Jazakallah Khair. (Mohammed Islam)

    Reply
    • Salaam Mohammed – I have deep sympathies for you – my personal inclination in your situation would be to (a) either move out of London though I know that’s difficult; or (b) if moving out of London is really really not possible, then get a conventional mortgage.

      But you should actually get a fatwa on this – Sh. Haitham Al Haddad or Sh. Suhaib Hassan might be good people to go to.

      Reply
  • السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
    May Allah reward you both and those who’ve helped you compile all the useful information across this site.

    I want to mention a few issues which I’ve noticed with regards to the argument of those who prefer to rent regardless (myself included) of “Islamic” mortgages being available or not. I’ve noticed that all the rental contracts that I’ve signed across the years have a clause stating that any late payments will be subjected to x amount of interest as per the Bank of England etc… check any short term tenancy agreement and you’ll see the exact wording.

    Now you may never be late on payment; however, as a hadeeth mentions, whoever witnesses a contract that contains riba is cursed. In this case, there’s always a problem whether renting or not, unless the contract can (and should) be changed. Maybe with Muslim landlords, but non Muslims and especially agents, I imagine this will be difficult to do.

    Have you or anyone else heard this being mentioned to a scholar on this subject?

    At this point, I’m favouring an “Islamic” mortgage, as it seems to be the lesser of evils. However, I’m confused about the criticism from the Shaykhs who are sceptical about Al rayan and others. Have the likes of Shaykh Haitham concluded that Ar Rayan and others are leading us to hidden riba mortgages or is it just other violations of Islamic fiqh that aren’t on the same scale as riba?

    If they are void of riba, then in the current state of Muslim affairs in the UK, especially with rental contracts including riba clauses, it seems better that we should use these Islamic banks and help them to survive. The hope as well is that these Banks will improve “Islamically”, by correcting the issues mentioned in the various criticism.

    What would you guys say about this? I’d like to hear your thoughts. (BTW I’m not asking for a fatwa)

    جزاك لله خيرا

    Hakim

    Reply
  • Mohammed Islam
    January 16, 2020 11:55 am

    Assalamu-Alaikum brother Ibrahim Khan,

    I pray that this NEW YEAR is going really well for you. Jazakallah khair for your advice. I really appreciate it.

    I have been trying but have been unable to make an appointment to meet Sheikh Haitham.

    Just wondering if you could advise on whether any of the following 2 processes will be halal in my case.

    Option 1 : Take out a conventional mortgage on a fixed 5 year term and then pay off the debt entirely within the 5 years.

    Option 2 : Take out a conventional mortgage on a fixed 5 year term and then transfer to one of the Halal mortgages (gatehouse or Al Rayan) within the 5 year term.

    In both cases the rate is fixed so will this be HALAL for the 5 years atleast ?

    Are there any other options ?

    Thanks again for your help. Look forward to hearing from you soon.

    Mohammed

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.
You need to agree with the terms to proceed

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

How to get a cheap Islamic mortgage/halal mortgage and save money
Are preference shares halal? Plus 6 solutions for venture capital
Every British Muslim needs a will. IFG Wills is an affordable quality option entirely online.

Follow IFG

YouTube
Get exclusive tips, resources and courses delivered straight to your inbox from IFG.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Menu