UK Stock Broker Comparison | Sharia Analysis

Choosing an online stockbroker is essential to your investing journey but it is often a rather painful process to work out who to go for. In this article we’ve tried to take some of that pain away by doing a detailed comparison and sharing our personal experiences too.

To start investing, you need to decide on the broker that you will invest through. Once you have a brokerage account, you can transfer money in and out of it – like a bank account.

Below we have compiled a comparison between a number of different types of stockbrokers in the UK. This is not an exhaustive list but it does cover off the various different flavours of brokers you can get – from the large institutional types, to the no-commission challengers, to the high street banks.

Make sure you read the helpful pointers and tips in the sections below the comparison too!

NameAsset optionsCostsAccount TypesAccount MinimumFeesTools/FunctionalitiesEducation resourcesSecurity FeaturesTrustpilot ratingCustomer ServiceRegulationNotesShariah ComplianceDo IFG use it?Link
AJ BellShares, funds, investment trusts and bonds0.25 percent custody charge, £1.50 for funds and £9.95 for shares ISA, General, SIPP£500Variable. £3.50 per month for ISAAppVideos, research tools, Shares magazineEncryption4.1Helpdesk receiving calls.FCA and FSCSOne of the largest brokers in the UK. Investment ideas’- specialist resourcesNAYesGet Started
DegiroShares, Funds, Bonds£1.75 plus 0.014% per share. Currency conversion 0.1%. Real time figures - £4.50 per monthGeneral£0£1.75 plus 0.014% per LSE transaction. These vary depending on exchange and fundAppBlog (insights and ideas). Investor’s academy.Secure structure protects investors from liquidation.4.1Calls from Monday to Friday 7am to 9pm. Email access.FCA and ICS (Dutch)- only €20,000 euros guaranteed.Real time prices, immediate trades, order by amount, Investor’s academy for education resources. Just make sure you purify any interest earned and make sure you don't tick the box where they allow your shares to be be loaned for short-selling.YesGet Started
EtoroStocks, Funds, Crypto, commodities, 0% commission. Fees calculated on daily basis. $5 withdrawal fee. General£200$5 withdrawal feeApp, Demo accountMarket analysis, podcast, News and insights, learning lab, trading school.2 factor authentication. segregated account for funds.2.1Livechat.FCA and CySec, FSCSEtoro absorbs Stamp Duty tax. Copy Trading feature, offline trading, charts, insights from analysts, social network community of investors.No obvious issues but stay away from their CFD and forex offering as that is haram. Also don't leverage or short-sell shares as that too is typically seen as impermisisble.NoGet Started
FreetradeStocks, Funds, investment trusts£0 commission. £9.99 per monthISA, General, SIPP£2£3 per monthAppForum, blog posts and articlesWaive liability for any breaches of security and instruct users to keep app updated and protect account details.4.0FAQs, email, and live chat 8 am-9 pm Weekdays 10 am-5 pm WeekendFCA and FSCSCustomisable auto-investment option.No obvious issues.NoGet Started
HalifaxShares, Funds, Bonds£12.50 per trade. 1.25% exchange rate for international trading. Transaction and ongoing charge for fundsISA, General, SIPP£0£36 annual customer administration fee and £12.50 per online tradeAppMarket News, Insight articles.Technology and safeguards that meet or exceed industry standards.1.6Calls from Monday to Friday 8am to 7pm. Web chat.FCA and FSCSInvestor meets Company service, Investment Ideas.No obvious issues.NoGet Started
Hargreaves LandsdownShares, bonds, Funds, Investment trustsMax charge of £11.95 per UK deal, max annual charge of 0.45% on funds, max fee of 1% charged on foreign exchange. Currency conversion 1%ISA, General, SIPP.£1Variable, for ISA £45 annually on fund investmentsAppFactsheets, market reports, newspaper round-ups, live share prices, Encryption3.2Helpdesk receiving calls.FCA and FSCSOne of the largest brokers in the UK. Analyst resources, automated investing.No obvious issues.YesGet Started
Interactive investorShares, Funds, investment trusts, bonds£9.99 a month, £7.99 for all UK and US trades. Streaming prices and real-time portfolio management (£20 per month). Currency conversion 1.5%ISA, General, SIPP.£0£10 per month flat fee regardless of volumeAppInsight resources - impartial editorial, rated lists and portfolios Face & Touch ID, Encrypted data4.7Calls from Monday to Friday 0745 to 1730. Email access.FCA and FSCSFlat fee structure, free daily newsletters and market update emails, discussion forums, multiple portfolio watchlists, track shares, notes on investments Ranges across 17 stock exchanges.No obvious issues.NoGet Started
Trading 212Indices, commodities, stocks, forex£0 commission. Currency conversion 0.5%ISA, General, CFD£1FreeApp, Demo account.Youtube channel with weekly content24x7 Security Operations Center, security audits and regular external security tests4.324-7 assistanceFCA and FSCSCustomisable auto-investment option. Don't open a general account with them - only the ISA. As in their general account they lend the shares out for short-selling. Also stay away from their CFD offering as that is haram. Also don't leverage or short-sell shares as that too is typically seen as impermisisble.NoGet Started

Right – Broker Sorted – What Should I Buy?

Check out our Halal Investment page here which helpfully compares between dozens of funds and other investment options available today.

ISA/SIPP and Tax-Saving Considerations

Brokerage accounts are subject to Capital Gains Tax (on profits over £12,300 a year) and and Dividend tax (on dividend profits over £2,000 a year).

If you’re thinking of investing regularly and think you’ll exceed those thresholds in terms of profits, you may want to use an Individual Savings Account (ISA) or a Self-Invested Personal Pension (SIPP) rather than opening a brokerage account due to their tax advantages.

But bear in mind, each ISA is limited to investing £20,000 per year. On the other hand, there are no limits to how much you can invest in a SIPP but tax relief will only apply to a maximum investment limit of £40,000 per year and there are restrictions on how and when you can withdraw the money.

When a brokerage account is right/not right

If you want to purchase and manage your own investments, a brokerage account at an online broker is for you (and the comparison table above is for you). Other options you may want to consider is a managed brokerage account (where your money is managed for you- which you pay for) or a robo-investor/advisor such as Wahed Invest for those that want to be hands-off.

Sharia considerations: CFD Trading, Margin Trading

When opening an account, you may be given the option of a cash account, a margin account or an account that involves CFDs. Margin accounts allow you to borrow money (with interest) from the broker to make trades – this is of course haram so stick to the cash account. Any account involving CFDs (Contract For Differences) are also haram as CFDs enable profiting from price movement without ever owning the underlying assets.

Important Factors to Consider in a Broker

What will you invest in? What features are important to you? What will cost less in light of the aforementioned? If you are a beginner, you should also consider the ease of use, education support, and access to market research.

A few notes of caution

Remember: don’t invest money you need within the next few years because just as you can profit through investing, you can also lose money. How you’re taxed will depend on your circumstances, and the rules can change.

How to Learn Halal Investing Quickly

If you want more information on investing, be sure to  check out our course on halal investing for busy professionals.


Keep Reading

2 Comments. Leave new

  • Thank you for the article I would like to highlight that e-Toro is actually an Israeli social trading and multi-asset brokerage company.

  • Thank you for the article, I would like to highlight that e-Toro is actually an Israeli social trading and multi-asset brokerage company.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.
You need to agree with the terms to proceed

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Are SPAC Investments Haram or Halal?
Will House Prices Go Down In 2021? | IFG
Every British Muslim needs a will. IFG Wills is an affordable quality option entirely online.
Get exclusive tips, resources and courses delivered straight to your inbox from IFG.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.